Human Rights Advocate and Electronic Editorial Journalist :focus on issuesues of Women s Rights, Human Rights in Iran, Founder: Tenth Wall Defense of Baha'i s in Iran and #TenthWall
twiterhero.blogspot.com – Finding followers free fast with nothing to buy using the Twitter.com follow button, not some fake twitter followers adder bot. No twitter followers for sale here, connect with real accounts that a…
markgeoffreykirshner.com – The physicist James Bullock explains how a complicated “dark sector” of interacting particles may illuminate some puzzling observations of the centers of galaxies. Source: Dark Matter May Be More C…
orbala.wordpress.com – While many Muslims prefer to deny this, Islam is *not* a simple religion (no religion is a simple religion), and there’s no such thing as just one Islam–okay, fine, one understanding of Islam–that …
uatoday.tv – ‘Our society does not understand the meaning of culture’ – Hermitage Director A decision by the Russian authorities to stop police protection of the national museums raised concern among the art lo…
theguardian.com – A Ukrainian national guardsman has died and many more have been injured in clashes with nationalist protesters outside parliament in Kiev, the interior minister said. A Reuters TV cameraman at the …
ucanews.com – Fifteen Rohingya candidates have been barred from running in Myanmar’s upcoming elections, adding to fears it is part of the mass disenfranchisement of a long-embattled ethnic minority group ahead …
france24.com – According to lawyer Eric Dupond-Moretti, representing the North African kingdom, journalists Eric Laurent and Catherine Graciet were involved in a “thug’s racket”. They were arrested after meeting …
nytimes.com – AHMEDABAD, India — The resentment built slowly in Hardik Patel. It took root when he watched his younger sister lose out on a college scholarship because of India’s version of affirmative action, a…
asafeworldforwomen.org – By Peter Hilton, Global Correspondent for Safeworld The ‘jungle’ camp outside Calais has been growing ever denser and increasingly is looking more likely to become a permanent fixture on the Anglo-…
nationalinterest.org – Both China and Russia appear to be building unmanned aerial vehicles designed to negate America’s advantages in stealth aircraft. Earlier this year, photos first emerged of a new High Altitude, Lon…
washingtonpost.com – (Tony Avelar / Bloomberg) A million users in a day isn’t cool. You know what’s cool? A billion. That’s right: Facebook just hit a huge milestone, announcing that earlier this week a billion people …
blog.iuniverse.com – iUniverse’s Douglas Gardham, author of The Actor and The Drive In, has significantly bolstered his marketing presence through engaging in book signings, and recently reached the milestone of sellin…
bloomberg.com – Indian Oil Corp. is seeking to build a $3 billion petrochemicals plant in Iran, according to people with direct knowledge of the matter. The plan hinges on assurances from Iran that the 1 million-t…
hra-news.org – HRANA News Agency – The following list is the information regarding the names, times of arrest, charge(s) and other information of some of the political prisoners in Sanandaj prison. Need to be men…
twiterhero.blogspot.com – Finding followers free fast with nothing to buy using the Twitter.com follow button, not some fake twitter followers adder bot. No twitter followers for sale here, connect with real accounts that a…
markgeoffreykirshner.com – The physicist James Bullock explains how a complicated “dark sector” of interacting particles may illuminate some puzzling observations of the centers of galaxies. Source: Dark Matter May Be More C…
orbala.wordpress.com – While many Muslims prefer to deny this, Islam is *not* a simple religion (no religion is a simple religion), and there’s no such thing as just one Islam–okay, fine, one understanding of Islam–that …
uatoday.tv – ‘Our society does not understand the meaning of culture’ – Hermitage Director A decision by the Russian authorities to stop police protection of the national museums raised concern among the art lo…
theguardian.com – A Ukrainian national guardsman has died and many more have been injured in clashes with nationalist protesters outside parliament in Kiev, the interior minister said. A Reuters TV cameraman at the …
ucanews.com – Fifteen Rohingya candidates have been barred from running in Myanmar’s upcoming elections, adding to fears it is part of the mass disenfranchisement of a long-embattled ethnic minority group ahead …
france24.com – According to lawyer Eric Dupond-Moretti, representing the North African kingdom, journalists Eric Laurent and Catherine Graciet were involved in a “thug’s racket”. They were arrested after meeting …
nytimes.com – AHMEDABAD, India — The resentment built slowly in Hardik Patel. It took root when he watched his younger sister lose out on a college scholarship because of India’s version of affirmative action, a…
asafeworldforwomen.org – By Peter Hilton, Global Correspondent for Safeworld The ‘jungle’ camp outside Calais has been growing ever denser and increasingly is looking more likely to become a permanent fixture on the Anglo-…
nationalinterest.org – Both China and Russia appear to be building unmanned aerial vehicles designed to negate America’s advantages in stealth aircraft. Earlier this year, photos first emerged of a new High Altitude, Lon…
washingtonpost.com – (Tony Avelar / Bloomberg) A million users in a day isn’t cool. You know what’s cool? A billion. That’s right: Facebook just hit a huge milestone, announcing that earlier this week a billion people …
blog.iuniverse.com – iUniverse’s Douglas Gardham, author of The Actor and The Drive In, has significantly bolstered his marketing presence through engaging in book signings, and recently reached the milestone of sellin…
bloomberg.com – Indian Oil Corp. is seeking to build a $3 billion petrochemicals plant in Iran, according to people with direct knowledge of the matter. The plan hinges on assurances from Iran that the 1 million-t…
hra-news.org – HRANA News Agency – The following list is the information regarding the names, times of arrest, charge(s) and other information of some of the political prisoners in Sanandaj prison. Need to be men…
The physicist James Bullock explains how a complicated “dark sector” of interacting particles may illuminate some puzzling observations of the centers of galaxies.
DARK MATTER—THE UNSEEN 80 percent of the universe’s mass—doesn’t emit, absorb or reflect light. Astronomers know it exists only because it interacts with our slice of the ordinary universe through gravity. Hence the hunt for this missing mass has focused on so-called WIMPs—Weakly Interacting Massive Particles—which interact with each other as infrequently as they interact with normal matter.
QUANTA MAGAZINE
ABOUT
Original story reprinted with permission from Quanta Magazine, an editorially independent division of the Simons Foundation whose mission is to enhance public understanding of science by covering research developments and trends in mathematics and the physical and life sciences
Physicists have reasons to look for alternatives to WIMPs. For two decades, astronomers have found less dark matter at the centers of galaxies than what WIMP models suggest they should. The discrepancy is even worse at the cores of the universe’s tiny dwarf galaxies, which have few ordinary stars but lots of dark matter.
About four years ago, James Bullock, a professor of physics and astronomy at the University of California, Irvine, began to wonder whether the standard view of dark matter was failing important empirical tests. “This was the point where I really started thinking hard about alternatives,” he said.
Bullock thinks that dark matter might instead be complex, something that interacts with itself strongly in the way that ordinary matter interacts with itself to form intricate structures like atoms and atomic elements. Such a self-interacting dark matter, Bullock suspects, could exist in a “dark sector,” somewhat parallel to our own light sector, but detectable only through the way it affects gravity.
He and his colleagues have created numerical simulations that predict what the universe would look like if dark matter feels strong interactions. They expected to see the model fail. Instead, they found that it was consistent with what astronomers observe.
Quanta Magazine spoke with Bullock about complex dark matter, how this mysterious mass might behave, and the best places in the universe to find it. An edited and condensed version of the interview follows.
QUANTA MAGAZINE: What do we know about dark matter?
JAMES BULLOCK: We are confident that it’s there, that it has mass, and that it tugs on itself and on other things via gravity. That’s about it. While dark matter has a gravitational tug, it doesn’t interact with normal matter—the stuff that makes up you and me—in a very intense way. It doesn’t shine. It’s invisible. It’s transparent. It doesn’t glow when it gets hot. Unfortunately, those are the ways astronomers usually study the universe; we usually follow the light.
So we don’t know what it’s made of?
We’ve come to understand that we can describe the world that we experience by the Standard Model of particle physics. We think of the particles that make up you and me as being broken down into constituent things, like quarks, and those quarks combine into neutrons and protons. There is a complicated dance that allows these particles to interact in certain ways. It gives rise to the periodic table of elements and all of the vast complexity we see around us. Just 20 percent of the mass of the universe is all of this complexity.
On the other hand, dark matter makes up something like 80 percent of the mass. First-guess models for what it is suggests that it is one particle that doesn’t really interact with much of anything—WIMPs. These are collisionless, meaning when two dark matter particles come at each other they basically go through each other.
Another possibility is this 80 percent of the universe is also complex. Maybe there’s something interesting going on in what’s called the dark sector. We know that whatever ties us to the dark matter is pretty weak or else we would have already seen it. This observation has led to the belief that all the interactions that could be going on with dark matter are weak. But there’s another possibility: When dark matter particles see themselves, there are complex and potentially very strong interactions. There even could be dark atoms and dark photons.
Those two worlds—this dark sector and our own sector—only communicate by gravity and perhaps other weak processes, which haven’t yet been seen.
How can you probe this dark sector if you can’t interact with it?
Now what we’re talking about doing is not just looking at the gross properties of the dark matter but the very makeup of the dark matter, too. The most obvious place to see those effects is where dark matter is bunched up. We believe the centers of galaxies and galaxy clusters are densest. And so by studying the behavior of dark matter by indirect methods—basically by the dynamics of stars and gas and galaxies in galaxy clusters—we can start to understand how dark matter is distributed in space. To start to discriminate between models, we can compare differences in dark matter’s spatial clumpiness in simulations, for example, and then look for those differences in data.
What does the data say?
In models using cold, collisionless dark matter—WIMPs—the dark matter is very dense at the middle of galaxies. It appears that those predicted densities are much higher than what’s observed.
What might be going on is that something a little more complex is happening in the dark sector, and that complexity is causing these slight disagreements between theory and observation at places where the dark matter is really clumped or starts congregating, like in the centers of galaxies or the centers of galaxy clusters.
I’m interested in running cosmological simulations of how the universe should evolve from the very beginning until now. I look at what happens, when I run those simulations forward, if I allow cold dark matter to occasionally collide and exchange energy. The simulations start with a small, almost-smooth primordial universe and end with beautiful agreement with large-scale structure—galaxies stretched out across the universe in the way we observe them. But the hearts of galaxies are less dense in dark matter in my simulations than they are in simulations where the dark matter is cold and collisionless.
How long have researchers known about these disagreements between the models and the data?
We’ve known that there’s a bit of a problem at the centers of galaxies for about 20 years. At first it was thought maybe we’re interpreting the data wrong. And now the question comes down to: Does galaxy formation eject dark matter somehow, or do we need to modify our understanding of dark matter?
Why did you start looking into self-interacting dark matter?
The first paper exploring ideas that the dark matter might be more complex was in Physical Review Letters, April 2000, by David Spergel and Paul Steinhardt. I actually started working on this several years later when I began seeing papers from the particle physics community exploring these ideas. My initial reaction was, that couldn’t be true, because I had this prejudice that things work so well with collisionless dark matter.
In the first set of simulations we ran, we gave dark matter a cross-section with itself. The bigger the cross-section is, the higher the probability that these particles are going to run into one another in any given amount of time. We set the value of the cross-section to something we were convinced would be ruled out [by the data], but when we ran our simulation we found that we couldn’t see any difference between that model and the classic one. And so we thought maybe we don’t know quite as much as we thought we knew.
Then, we dialed it up and looked at a strong interaction similar to if you threw two neutrons together. We saw something that looks really close to observations on large scales but does produce differences in the hearts of galaxies. Rather than the dark matter getting denser and denser as you approach the center of the galaxy, it reached a threshold density.
Could it be that these little discrepancies we’ve been seeing in the observational data are actually a clue that there’s something interesting and fun going on in the dark sector that we weren’t thinking about before?
How have these simulations evolved since the first ones you performed?
We’ve been running very high cross-section values to see when this model starts to break compared to some observations. We’re also focusing energy on including all of the star-formation and galaxy-formation physics in these simulations. The hardest part with these simulations is that the universe isn’t just made of dark matter. There’s all of this other annoying normal stuff that we have to think about, too. Gas that can turn into stars—and some of those stars are going to be so massive that they blow up as supernovae. When they blow up as supernovae, they are effectively jostling the gravitational field around them, and this jostling can potentially move the dark matter around. Is it possible that these discrepancies that we’re seeing in the observed densities of dark matter and the predicted densities of dark matter is because the galaxy-formation process itself is changing things in a way that we don’t understand very well?
Something else that I spend my time on is figuring out the cleanest and clearest cases for determining what comes from the physics of dark matter versus the physics of star formation and galaxy formation. We have to think hard about how clean our cosmological experiments are.
Where is that cleanest cosmological laboratory?
My opinion is that the cleanest sites are the teeniest, tiniest galaxies we know about—dwarf galaxies. They have very few stars but huge amounts of dark matter. In some cases they have 100 times as much dark matter within their visible extent as they have visible matter. (The Milky Way interior to the Sun is about half dark matter and half normal matter.) Dwarf galaxies have so much dark matter compared to their stars, they’re excellent laboratories for dark matter. They’re as clean as we have.
But studying dark matter physics in something that doesn’t give off much light is pretty difficult.
The nice thing about these objects is that a lot of them are really close by. They’re close enough that you can actually measure the velocities of individual stars. That allows you to build as precise a model as you can of the dark matter density at the centers of these galaxies. They’re close enough to study with great precision, but they’re chock full of dark matter so you don’t have to worry as much about what’s going on with the stars.
There have been recent observational studies focusing on galaxy clusters. Are observations and theoretical models starting to move in a similar direction?
Imagine a swarm of bees; a cluster of galaxies is sort of like that. Massive collisions, where two galaxy clusters have come at each other and pass through each other, are one place to look for complex dark matter. If the dark matter is strongly interacting, when those massive clusters come together, the galaxies will keep flying right on through, but the dark matter, because it’s strongly interacting with itself, will sort of bunch up in the middle.
In the famous example of the Bullet Cluster, astronomers used the effect of gravitational lensing to look at where the dark matter was. They found that the dark matter has moved right on through along with the galaxies, which is what you’d expect with collisionless dark matter. Because of this result, people said, “Well, there’s no way the dark matter is strongly interacting with itself.”
That was a few years ago and a couple things have happened since then. We’ve realized that a lot of the first-order estimates people have used to determine how much the dark matter ought to drag on itself were overestimated. Also, several other clusters have less-clear results, and in some cases maybe there is more drag than we thought before. Richard Massey’s group found evidence that some kind of dark pressure, ram pressure, is ripping the dark matter out of a galaxy.
We really aren’t at the point yet where I think we’ve done enough, though. We need to invest more effort into simulating the calculations properly with these various classes of dark matter to figure out what it is we know and what it is we don’t know. I think we’ve seen exciting hints, and they motivate us to try to do as well as we can to figure out what they mean.
Original story reprinted with permission from Quanta Magazine, an editorially independent publication of theSimons Foundation whose mission is to enhance public understanding of science by covering research developments and trends in mathematics and the physical and life sciences.
500px.com – The beach pictured here is called Wharariki (pronounced “far-a-ricky”) and the rock formations in the image are actually part of the Archway Islands. This beach is located at the extreme north top …
dailymail.co.uk – These stunning images of sunrise and sunset were taken over the course of four years by a photographer – who had just 15 minutes a day to capture them. Paul Reiffer, 35, travelled the globe catchin…
un.org – Since nuclear weapons testing began in the mid-twentieth century, with the first test on 16 July 1945, nearly 2,000 have taken place. There has been little consideration of the devastating effects …
theatlantic.com – Over the past month I’ve run a series of messages from readers in North America, the Middle East, Europe, and elsewhere about the JCPOA Iran-nuclear deal that the Congress will soon formally consid…
smh.com.au – Drowned in darkness: The body of a migrant lies on a dock, in Zuwara, Libya. Photo: AP Cairo: Up to 200 people were feared dead in the latest boat capsizing off the Libyan coast, as dozens of bodie…
hrw.org – Bosco Ntaganda Eluded International Justice for 7 Years The trial of the military commander Bosco Ntaganda for grave crimes in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo is scheduled to begin on Septembe…
philly.com – One of the most heinous of the endless war crimes of the Islamic State has been the systematic rape of thousands of young girls and women – who are sold as sex slaves. Most of the victims come from…
myhelpinghandspress.blogspot.com – Joy Ross Davis discusses her experience as the keynote speaker with the all-Alabama chapters of the Business and Professional Women (BPW). On July 18th I was fortunate enough to be the keynote spea…
blog.growth.supply – We live in The Age of Dramatic Distraction. Many shiny toys to chase every waking moment yet so few of those pursuits create real value and grow a life brilliantly lived. Too many of us are oversch…
diplomatartist.com – In the immediate aftermath of #Katrina, many around America blamed the death and destruction on New Orleans and its residents – some asked should the US simply abandon New Orleans? The pretext was …
washingtonpost.com – Thirty-two-year-old Mohammad Hasamur Rahman with his new bride, 15-year-old Nasoin Akhter, in Manikganj, Bangladesh. (Allison Joyce/Getty Images) On her wedding day, 15-year- old Nasoin Akhter look…
haaretz.com – JP UPDATES – Speaking at a rally against the Iran deal in front of the Jewish Children’s Museum in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn, New York State Assemblyman Dov Hikin compared Jewish leader…
entrepreneur.com – Starting a business can be difficult, both mentally and financially, and there are plenty of mistakes to be made. One common error among fledgling companies is invoicing. As a small-business owner,…
inhabitat.com – Park officials in the southern Australian province of Victoria say a deepwater reef has been discovered there that may have more coral, sponge, and fish than the Great Barrier Reef. The reef is in …
iranpresswatch.org – According to the “No Campaign ‒ No to Abuse and Imprisonment of Baha’i Residents”, on Monday 24 August, agents of the Intelligence and Security services have shut down City water for residents of t…
i24news.tv – G. Haas montre une caricature insultante de Netanyahou; le Parquet viennois accusé d’ignorer l’antisémitisme La Suisse a exprimé ses regrets vendredi après que son ambassadeur à Téhéran a montré un…
At the beginning of the Fourth Century CE the Roman Empire was at its zenith. It had reorganized successfully into two manageable halves, stood the pressure from the Persian Empire, acquired a new state religion and reworked its finances and public administration to a stellar state. Within a dozen years after that the Empire began to suffer serious stresses which would ultimately culminate in the loss of Thrace, Spain, Gaul and North Africa, accounting for considerable revenue, and eventually the complete collapse of its Western half.
Historians blame a series of “barbarian” invasions for this calamity. In fact, the ultimate cause was far away in Asia. The pastoral Huns were suffering serious ecological disruptions and their bloody and cruel raids pushed the Germanic nations across the Roman frontiers. These Germans were no “Barbarians”, they had been Romanized for generations, somewhat uneasily. It can be said they were facing their “struggle…
Tenth Wall Defense 4 Human Rights
@MarkGKirshner
HEADLINES VIDEOSWORLDLEISUREMORE
Friday, Aug. 28, 2015 Next update in about 21 hours Archives
twiterhero.blogspot.com – Finding followers free fast with nothing to buy using the Twitter.com follow button, not some fake twitter followers adder bot. No twitter followers for sale here, connect with real accounts that a…
Australia confiscated 650,000 guns. Murders and suicides plummeted.
vox.com – The on-camera shooting of two Virginia reporters Wednesday morning seems bound to evoke, like so many shootings before it, some sort of national conversation about gun control. Which means there wi…
Heritage expert inspects Nalanda for Unesco tag
thehindu.com – An expert from Paris-based International Council of Monuments and Sites is visiting the ruins of the Nalanda University to evaluate India’s bid to get the ancient site inscribed in the Unesco World…
The ‘saddest bride I have ever seen’: Child marriage is as popular as ever in Bangladesh
washingtonpost.com – Thirty-two-year-old Mohammad Hasamur Rahman with his new bride, 15-year-old Nasoin Akhter, in Manikganj, Bangladesh. (Allison Joyce/Getty Images) On her wedding day, 15-year- old Nasoin Akhter look…
Just Out Of Jail, Ethiopian Leader Brings A Sharp Message To Obama
npr.org – Just a few months ago, Bekele Gerba was languishing in a high security Ethiopian jail, hearing the cries of fellow prisoners being beaten and tortured. Now, the 54-year-old foreign language profess…
Subscribe to the Email Newsletter
Filamentary Networks of Electric Currents Pervade Space | Space News
The Cranberries – Dreams (subtitulado)
Tracy Chapman – Give Me One Reason (Live 11/13)
Overview of Resilience
Shared by
svetlyac powerblog
Iranians flee human rights abuses – 10 Dec 09
All Videos →
WORLD
Migrant crisis: Libya boats capsize off Zuwara carrying hundreds – BBC News
bbc.com – Hundreds of people are feared dead after two boats carrying up to 500 migrants capsized off the Libyan city of Zuwara, residents and officials say. The first boat, which signalled for help early on…
Voices in Danger: How can we prevent journalists from being sexually assaulted in conflict zones?
independent.co.uk – One female journalist commented that in some countries, “It is no longer that a woman might be sexually violated or harassed, but that a woman now will be sexually violated if attempting to report …
Saudi preacher who killed his daughter released
UNHCR viewpoint: ‘Refugee’ or ‘migrant’ – Which is right?
Illegal and Prolonged Confinement of Bahareh Hedayat, Iranian Human Rights Advocate
Gaza protesters ask Egypt to bring back 4 Palestinians missing in Sinai
All World →
LEISURE
The Artist Who Puts Couples in Vacuum Packs | VICE | United States
vice.com – Since 2009, Haruhiko “Photographer Hal” Kawaguchi has made a career out of asking couples he doesn’t know to come home and get in the bag. Not many people could pull something like that off, but th…
Find Your Passion With These 7 Simple Ways!
redshoemovement.com – The idea that finding your passion is the best way to advance in your career is finally catching on. Here are 7 ways to find your passion that will bring home this often-elusive concept. Maybe you’…
Helping Hands Press: We all need to be more Amish-Roger Rheinheimer
Shared by
Flora Reigada
Two sisters to be raped as punishment – demand justice
All Leisure →
ART & ENTERTAINMENT
Writing, Guest Post from Douglas Gardham, author of The Drive In
Shared by
Douglas Gardham
fictiontofruition.weebly.com – Title: The Drive In Author: Douglas Gardham Publisher: iUniverse Pages: 130 Genre: Short Stories Format: Kindle/Paperback Have you ever been intrigued by what mysteries lie behind the doors and wi…
First Poster Of ‘Steve Jobs’ Movie Starring Michael Fassbender Emerges
Sexual exploitation of children: UN rights expert launches official visit to Japan
All Art & Entertainment →
POLITICS
End death penalty, keep it for terror only: Law Commission
indianexpress.com – In what will be a reversal of its earlier stand, the Law Commission of India is set to recommend abolition of death penalty in the country. A 272-page draft report of the Law Commission, circulated…
Official visit to Bangladesh by the UN Special Rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief
Shared by
AmisIran
ISIS targeting children for recruitment
AmisIran
All Politics →
SCIENCE
The Next Revolution in Photography Is Coming
time.com – It’s time to stop talking about photography. It’s not that photography is dead as many have claimed, but it’s gone. Just as there’s a time to stop talking about girls and boys and to talk instead a…
neuroscience
Rising sea level threatens coastal restoration, New Orleans levees, scientists say
All Science →
TECHNOLOGY
Sophisticated Phishing Campaign Targets Iranian Diaspora
voanews.com – Civil society activists in the Iranian diaspora community are being targeted with an elaborate and sophisticated phishing campaign designed to steal their email communications and contacts, a group…
Here’s How Iran Resets Your Gmail Password
All Technology →
#IRANELECTION
Iran is premiering their $40 million dollar movie about the childhood of the prophet Muhammad
businessinsider.com – Iran’s most expensive movie, “Muhammad”, which chronicles the childhood of the Muslim prophet, opened nationwide on Thursday, winning praise from early audiences. Directed by Majid Majidi, the 171-…
Iran Renews Support For Hamas Terrorists
How Social Media Has Helped Amir Hekmati, an American Imprisoned in Iran
Building Khavaran Cultural Centre on Ruins of Baha’i Cemetery! – Iran Press Watch
Cheetah Conservation Day aims to protect species in Iran
Shared by
AmisIran
A Report on the Situation of Misagh Yazdan Nejad in Rajai Shahr Prison
All #iranelection →
#IRAN
Bedbugs Have Put Prisoners of Ward 8 of Evin Prison in a Difficult Situation
hra-news.org – HRANA News Agency – Bedbug bites and insect stings have exhausted prisoners in ward 8 of Evin prison. According to the report of Human Rights Activists News Agency in Iran (HRANA), bedbug bites and…
Ebrahim Firuzi Ended His Hunger Strike after 5 Days
Aliasghar Mahmoudian Has to Serve More Due To Medical Furlough
A Citizen of Afghanistan Died in the Iranian Refugee Camp
Berlin orchestra’s planned Tehran concert angers Israel
Tehran street named after “Angel for Kids with Cancer” – Real Iran
It is not too late to strengthen the Iran deal, a prominent critic says.
Source: Robert Satloff’s 10 Questions for President Obama on the Iran Nuclear Deal – The Atlantic
10 Questions for President Obama About Iran It is not too late to strengthen the Iran deal, a prominent critic says.
One person who has been talking about the need to strengthen the deal, and who has been raising questions about the deal’s potential unintended consequences, is Robert Satloff, the executive director of the Washington Institute for Near East Policy.
During the course of a lengthy email exchange with me over the past several days, Satloff generated a list of 10 questions he would like to ask President Obama about the deal. Here are Satloff’s questions to the president:
1. You have argued that the Iran deal enhances Israel’s security and those of our Arab Gulf allies. At the same time, your administration has offered the Gulf states a huge security package by way of compensation and you have expressed frustration that the government of Israel has not yet entered into discussions with you to discuss ways to bolster its security. But isn’t this a paradox? If the Iran deal bolsters their security, shouldn’t their security needs be going down, not up?
2. It is surely legitimate for you to argue that the Iran deal enhances U.S. security but it certainly seems odd for you to claim to understand Israel’s security needs more than its democratically elected leaders. Are there other democracies whose leaders you believe don’t recognize their own best security interests or is Israel unique in this regard?
3. Constructive, respected, well-informed observers, like your former [National Security Council] Iran policy advisor Dennis Ross, have urged you to propose transferring to Israel the “mountain-busting” Massive Ordnance Penetrator as a way to boost Israel’s independent deterrence against Iran. But you have not done so. Instead, in your letter to Congressman [Jerrold] Nadler, you highlighted your administration’s plan to send Israel a much less capable weapon. Why are you reluctant to send Israel the best item we have in our inventory to address this profound threat?
4. You have said that the Iran nuclear agreement provides a peaceful, diplomatic resolution to the threat of nuclear proliferation in the Middle East. Would you agree, therefore, that the pursuit of an independent nuclear option by another Middle East country—say, Saudi Arabia—would be clear evidence that the Iran deal had failed?
5. In your letter to Congressman Nadler, you refused to spell out the penalties Iran would suffer for violations of the agreement, saying that “telegraphing in advance to Iran the expected response for any potential infractions would be counterproductive, potentially lessening the deterrent effect.” On the surface, this is difficult to understand—after all, as a constitutional law professor, you can appreciate that having clarity in terms of penalties for lawbreaking is a basic element of our legal system. If you aren’t willing to publicly spell out this approach to penalties, can you guarantee that the United States and its European partners have already agreed, in writing, on precisely what actions they will collectively take in response to different types of infractions? Will you share these details with at least the leaders of the relevant committees in Congress? Or is the real reason you aren’t willing to “telegraph” these penalties in advance [is] because we and the Europeans can’t agree on them?
6. In your letter to Congressman Nadler, you also said you “reserved the right to deploy new sanctions to address continuing concerns.” Can you spell out what sort of new sanctions you have in mind? Specifically, wouldn’t it make sense for you to ask Congress to articulate new sanctions now that would come into effect if our intelligence agencies reported that Iran was using its sanctions-relief windfall to transfer large sums (or expensive weapons systems) to its allies and terrorist proxies?
7. You have argued that the global sanctions regime falls apart if Congress rejects the Iran deal. But the key variable here is not Europe, China or some other foreign country—it’s the United States. Specifically, the sanctions regime only collapses if the U.S. stops enforcing the sanctions with the same vigor it has enforced them [with] in recent years, and instead goes back to the policy of the Clinton and Bush administrations, which refused to enforce ILSA [Iran and Libya Sanctions Act] despite overwhelming votes for that law in Congress. In the event of a “no” vote, can you promise that your administration will expend the same effort and resources to enforce U.S. sanctions laws against Iran as has been the case the last few years? And if that’s the case, what’s your explanation for how or why sanctions will collapse?
8. The supreme leader clearly wants the benefits of the deal—both in terms of sanctions relief and the international validation it brings for Iran’s nuclear program. Yet you seem to bend over backwards to be wary of saying things that might upset him. (Given the supreme leader’s continued hostility toward America, this is a characteristic that he doesn’t seem to share.) Specifically, in your letter to Congressman Nadler, why did you resort once again to the “all options are on the table” formulation in the event Iran dashes toward a bomb? Since a “dash” implies Iran would be hell-bent toward achieving its goal, why not state bluntly that we would use force to stop them? If they are dashing, haven’t they already violated the core commitment in the Iran agreement not to pursue a weapon? If they are dashing, the threat of renewed sanctions surely isn’t an effective deterrent. Wouldn’t candor produce more deterrence than subtlety?
9. In your American University speech, you said the Iran agreement produced a “permanent” solution to the threat of the Iranian nuclear bomb. But just a few months ago, you told an NPR interviewer that Iran’s breakout time toward a bomb “would have shrunk almost down to zero” when restrictions on centrifuges and enrichment expire in after 10-15 years. Can both statements really be true?
10. In your final debate with Mitt Romney in October 2012, just before you came before American voters for the final time, moderator Bob Schieffer asked you specifically what sort of Iran deal you would accept. Your response was: “The deal we’ll accept is that they end their nuclear program.” Notwithstanding the significant achievements of the Iran agreement, it clearly falls short of “ending their nuclear program.” Moreover, you and your spokespeople regularly disparage as warmongers those who advocate what you once called for. Why did your own position in 2012 become warmongering by 2015?